Two deep-seated concerns have resurfaced in the world’s
media this week, with regard to Russia’s capability of hosting two major
sporting events: the 2014 Winter Olympics in Sochi and the 2018 World Cup. As
ever with an the Olympics, people have questioned the cost and time management
of Sochi’s organising committee, but on this occasion, it is the social
problems of homophobia and racism that are attracting the headlines. Given my
current location, I want to offer an insider’s view on both of these issues.
This week, thousands of people have been adding their
signatures to a petition, calling for the Coca Cola brand to withdraw their
sponsorship from Sochi 2014, in order to condemn Russia’s new laws on
homosexuality, which were passed in June earlier this year. The law banned the
‘propaganda of non-traditional sexual relations’ and means it is illegal to
give children any information about homosexuality. Basically, it is illegal to
demonstrate homosexual affection in public. But, unlike the international media
insists on reporting, this is not a direct attack on homosexual people. In
fact, Putin claims that this law defends homosexual citizens from violent,
‘anti-gay’ activists, as it should discourage people from inciting homophobic
hatred. Furthermore, the law is aimed at arresting the fall in Russia’s birth
rate, promoting same sex, ‘traditional’ relationships, to spark population
growth. Nevertheless, it is a backward step. For me, these reasons don’t carry
enough weight. Arguably, the government is responsible for not sorting out
Russia’s homophobic attitude years ago, and this is their attempt to sweep the
issue under the rug. But in a world where the legalisation of same sex marriage
is becoming more and more common, you just can’t conceal an issue like this.
In all honesty, I’ve seen little evidence of homophobia out
here, though of course, I can’t really speak from direct experiences. Last
week, I was asked if I was gay by a no-nonsense sort of man who had seemingly
based his judgement on the fact that I was travelling with a male companion.
Also, I chose not to bring some of my more extravagant items of clothing with
me, in attempt to avoid attracting attention to myself, but with hindsight I
don’t feel that was necessary. Regarding Sochi, the eyes of the world will be
on Russia, but I hope that the sport won’t be overshadowed by violent clashes
and protests. I believe that Russia needs to reanalyse its attitude, but
forcing the issue isn’t the right way to instigate the change.
The second issue that has sparked into life this week is the
racism demonstrated towards black footballers. Before the European
Championships in Poland and the Ukraine last year many people expressed
concerns, but I don’t remember there being any problems there. I don’t see why
the same thing can’t happen in 2018. Yes, some black players are occasionally
subjected to racist abuse in Russia, but it is only a small portion of
supporters, rather than the entire crowd. I have been to three football matches
in Tomsk and at no point did I witness any racial abuse. The most high profile
of these matches was against league leaders Zenit St Petersburg, some of whose
fans infamously stated that they didn’t want any black players on their team,
not long after signing Brazil’s Hulk and Belgium’s Axel Witsel. However, both
players played in the away trip to Tom Tomsk FC and endured no racist chanting.
Like in England, the main aim of both sets of ‘Ultras’ (loud, formidable fans,
believed by many to have extreme political and racial views) is to intimidate
the opposition with noise, and to out-sing their counterparts. It would be very
unfair to label all Russia’s football supporters as racist, just as it is
unfair to say that everyone is homophobic, because it tends to be a small minority
of people causing the problems. This small minority has caused Manchester
City’s Yaya Toure to call for a boycott of the 2018 World Cup by black players.
I understand that even one player being subjected to racial abuse is
unacceptable, but a boycott of the tournament won’t solve the problem. The
Russian FA and UEFA need to work together to stamp out the abuse. Whether it
means banning clubs from European competition or trying to target the specific
fans responsible, something needs to be done. Yaya Toure has rekindled the
debate and has got people talking about it. I believe it is these words
that will ultimately triumph in the fight against racism, hopefully before any
reckless, and potentially self-destructive, action is taken.
I’m not trying to downplay these issues; I just want to cast
them in a more realistic light. I love this country in so many ways and I don’t
want people to develop stereotypes based upon a few individuals. Of course, Russia
has to do something about homophobia, but it may not be possible before Sochi
2014. The re-education of a nation is not something that will happen in just a
few months. In my opinion, talking about these issues is the best way to
instigate change. Hopefully, these sporting events will show Russia the
benefits and brilliance of diverse races and sexual orientation to allow them
to move forward.